You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section. UNLESS a round hit near that superstructure, they would have no clue as to it being long or short. We have to remember that after loading the shells (which happens at a fixed angle, usually 5 degrees), the guns would have to be raised to the proper elevation. Bismark vs Bismarck, why does Bismark win??? How? With a travel time of roughly 36 seconds, I would personally think the average at that range would be around 45-50 sec per salvo to adjust and correct fall. This emphasis on long range fire would give Yamato a massive advantage in the opening stages of the battle, as they would be able to fire up on and perhaps even land hits on Bismarck as Bismarck tried to get Yamato within range of its own guns. 17 best images about navi ww2 on pinterest us navy world war and imperial japanese battleship iowa image search yamato vs class post treaty battleships the inglorius padre steve #39 s uss ijn of warships official forum They just could not contemplate the US Navy developing a shell like the super heavy at the time. "This turn was executed sometime between 0559-0600. Evaluations of Iowa's firecontrol lead to reports like this one: "Spotting both 5-inch and 16-inch splashes, HC or AP, with the radar is comparable to deliberately drawing a picture of the splashes on paper and looking at it. Yamamoto: Japanese Naval Officer or a fashion designer. At 20km, the inaccuracy was around 30-50m depending on day to night and weather since they had a special infrared set to use at night. We have a saying in the Marine Corps. The only difference was the Japanese one was far more resistant to shock. It means a simultaneous discharge of weapons. When is Yamato vulnerable to Bismarck's shells? A 4 to 5 gun salvo was common practice by 1925, the Gabelgruppen, is still a salvo. Not that anybody was trying to be be misleading but from my understanding the information available is suspect and from what I understand this is why: 1. When you start talking about crew traits with regards to the Japanese vs. Germans or versus anyone else, and begin labeling one group of people with equal training and just as legendary a sea culture as inferior... no idea where those concepts are coming from, I guess. Even in that situation, which could be considered "ideal" they fired over 100 rounds for 12 hits. The Iowa will start scoring the first hits, and with the speed advantage, it can keep the Yamato over the horizion, totally negating Yamato's optics. World of Warships - téléchargez et jouez au jeu en ligne multijoueur figurant des bateaux, faites partie de la communauté WoWS EU At what range is Bismarck a superior ship? Bismarck has little … With their speed advantage gone, the Germans find themselves in a slugging match with far larger, more heavily armored opponents. This almost comes off as a little... questionable in terms of political correctness. For the movie, see One Piece Film: Z. Bismarck (DKM BB) {A101} [1/700] (WW2) WL; POOR. You mention that Yamato was able to achieve a straddle quickly, but it still missed the target. Goddagames, June 3, 2014 in General Game Discussion. +1 on this. Iowa would be far more likely to achieve the first hit due to her vastly superior fire control. One of the Largest HP pools of all tech-tree Tier VIII Battleships. Now the only penetration values we know for certain for the vessel are the ones the US Intelligence obtained from a source in Japan for their 20km and 30km tests, as these were considered common engagement ranges for the vessels to be engaging the US Fleet. Hitler wouldn't have given a fig if the planned trade sweep had been abandoned. Bismarck would also be doing the same. The bismarck was fast, and had accurate long-range guns. However, unlike in real life, Yamato will actually have to contend with ships that were at least comparable. Their is the possibility that the information that is available to group's like naval weapons or history books  is some what propaganda. Her second was slightly over with 1 shell landing to starboard and 4 shells to port making it a partial straddle. By her 4th salvo she had a full straddle, but due to the size of the escort carriers and the size of her spread at that range it's hard to get a hit on something that small. Im sorry your math regarding Bismarck is wrong, Bismarck started firing with so called Gabelgruppen (4 projectiles from 2 turrets) with artifical increased spread (1 turret  firing at the calculated range and the second calculated Rang + 400 m) the second Gabelgruppe straddled the target (one turret firing a salvo at the corrected range and  and the other at -400 m). (Edit: Typo for 150cm search lights, accidentally typed 15cm). If the US Navy was stuck using the Mark 5 AP shell for their guns. At all ranges fired during this period, the most inexperienced officer, given a brief explanation of what to expect, can spot splashes accurately to within 100 yards, and to within 50 yards with some experience. That's 22.38 inches of belt armor not taking into account a slope on a belt. they would need to see the impact of the shell vs the target in order to do that, and the impact point is very much invisible. The effective range is not identical. Well the what we know about ships tech trees have it listed as 9. I mentioned Bismarcks turning radius for the sake of completion. Honestly, I think a better debate would be: could Bismarck and Tirpitz together sink Yamato? And at 37km, that's not an easy feat by any vessel of the time. In all situations the Yamato wins. IF, they engage in the Atlantic, specifically the North Atlantic the Bismarck has a far better chance. While a battleship is bigger, it is also moving at a much faster speed. While the Yamato could "see" the superstructure of the Iowa at long distance, it was totally useless for fire control. For this reason, the Yamato class was put to sea. Historically, the Panther mainly faced M4s and T-34s where as in WoT they face T29s, T20s, etc. USS White Plains had to go in for complete drydock and repairs due to all the damage that was done just from 1 near miss, including flooding, warping of its outer-bulkheads and damage to its deck. Without the both of those, even those 3 vessel classes would be in serious trouble. Hitler would have fallen off his Schloss in delight. I like rooting for under dogs and trolling. Six knots is a very big difference, you know. Rugged construction — coupled with elaborate subdivision into compartments and a vast expanse of armor — ensured a high level of endurance. Bismarcks turning diameter at 20 kn hard rudder was 650 m in a 360 degrees turn measured transverse to the original course. Especially important systems receive 100% redundancy plus special emergency circuits. Yamato would win and I don't think it would be close, either. No one including Japan had any experience building guns larger than 16 inches except the British and that was limited to the gun on Courageous. We will never know. Yes, it was difficult to hit moving ships from other moving ships. The Yamato class would have had an immunity range between 16000 and 29500 meters or roughly nearly 14km. The methodology of German Naval Gun designations changed three times in the first half of the 20th century. The effective range is the distance at which you can effectively be expected to hit something, and Yamato's firecontrol is not even in the same class as Iowa's. Rugged construction — coupled with elaborate subdivision into compartments and a vast expanse of armor — ensured a high level of endurance. Link to post Share on other sites [KHIF] … [The Band] Home; About Us; Discography; Merchandise; Blog; Contact Us; Blog ...German shells were in semi-casing..can be reached by diving projectiles, shells were stacked without casing on the middle platform deck. Die mächtige Hood war der Stolz der Royal Navy. So lets reduce that Iowa down to 35 feet above sealevel, where Yamato can see those primary turrets. World of Warships - Asia Language Based Communities ; English Speaking Community ; General Discussions ; Warship Comparison: Bismarck VS North Carolina Sign in to follow this . Yamato's turrets are impenetrable to the German 15" shell, and Yamato's shells can penetrate Bismarcks turrets at any range. How the heck do you know? The Nowaki was able to get away with only splinter damage. Bismarck intact? By contrast, Yamato had a 16" belt and a NINE INCH, at maximum, deck. She sank the world's largest battlecruiser, HMS Hood in the of the Denmark Strait, the wars' only equal engagement of large battleships (Bismarck and Prinz Eugen vs HMS Hood and Prince of Wales). Even the German fanboys agreed that the Bismarck did not stand a chance vs the Yamato based on its design. Note there has been an announcement by Aoshima of a newly tooled Bismarck to replace the above kit sometime in April of 2008. As for hitting the maneuvering Iowa, it would be about the same % as the Iowa due to those dispersions, and mind you, Yamato could see Iowa's superstructure at from the top ring of the funnels to the radar from 43.453km away. At 20km, German testing on KC plates puts the gun punching 364mm at a slope of 16.4 angle so that's about a 74 deg to vertical like the Yamato's. Hell, due to slope and effective LoS, at 15km the armor would be 456.16mm effective vs the Mark 5's 457mm of penetration. Considering Iowa's dispersion at that range was near 800m, good luck hitting the ship, oh wait, Yamato had a hard time hitting a carrier at that range with a straddle as well due to dispersion. We also already debunked that "over the horizon" crap with Iowa in the old thread so you can take that one to the recycling bin. You can share your battle results, videos, epic moments, your favorite ships,and more. Share this post. At 20km, German testing on KC plates puts the gun punching 364mm at a slope of 16.4 angle so that's about a 74 deg to vertical like the Yamato's. So which ship do you think had the better fire control? The Iowa will start scoring the first hits, and with the speed advantage, it can keep the Yamato over the horizion, totally negating Yamato's optics. But from what I read it is somewhat fragile. That's not to discredit the power of the Yammy, it would be an interesting fight and could go eitherway, but my money would be on the Bismarck. And again, the fact that Iowa WOULD be able to hit Yamato at ranges that Yamato would not have been able to effectively reply is a big one here. German crews were superior to Japanese? +1 on this. Hell, due to slope and effective LoS, at 15km the armor would be 456.16mm effective vs the Mark 5's 457mm of penetration. As all who have stated with hard, technical facts above, few (if any) of the big-gun warships ever created would have a chance against Yamato in a 1 vs 1 gun duel. It can't help but be better than this kit. This section is dedicated to World War II Warships of all fleets, covering all the belligerents in 1939 and operations from the 1st September 1939 shelling of the Polish Westerplatte by German Battleship Schleswig Holstein up to the Armistice in September 1945. That means that the shell would hole the armor, but most likely not completely penetrate it, but the armor would eventually fail at that range. This is often the case with government information anywhere. This Durchschlagatlas is basis of all calculations", please do not understand the remarks as a personal attack. Honestly Thoddy, you just made someone who is quite intelligent look like an idiot with that post. The "Diving" underwater characteristic of the shells performed better at shorter ranges due to the tighter spread and high velocity of the shells. EDIT: @ thiebodov, c'est un cuirassé classe Queen-Elizabeth je pense. A spotter would be needed. Without knowing entry speed, exit speed, duration of a 180/360 degrees turn, time until the ship reacts on the rudder, maximum heel etc a comparison may be misleading and speculative. 2. Honestly, even if it came down to North Carolina or South Dakota vs Yamato, I'd bet on the South Dakota/North Carolina... My money is on Bismarck, good luck to the crew of the Yamato in actually hitting Bismarck. Beginners are welcome. So I guess that damage doesn't count? In my opinion the only ship that could give the Yamato or Musashi a good fight would be a US Montana-Class BB or maybe the Iowa or South Dakota. A Salvo does not mean "All Guns". Still, Yamato had a smaller turning radius at a speed six knots higher. So unless James Cameron or Robert Ballard decide to dive it and find out themselves it will always be up in question. So you probably want to use that "But the Bismarck could fire 3 rounds per minute!". Bismarck opens fire on Yamato and Tirpitz on Musashi, with Bismarck scoring an early hit on the Japanese flagship. It isn't hard Paladin, you can do the calculations yourself. depending on the importance of the component. In that salvo there were, I think, two shots short and one over, but it may have been the other way round.". Who would win in a battle, The Super Battleship Yamato or The Battleship Bismark, Washington and those other 49 lesser states. Par contre je suis désolé mais la protection sous-marine du Yamato je … I have a strong feeling that many players will enjoy the Montana over the Yamato due to this very fact. Tirpitz has standard german 6km torps, so, if it happens you'll find yourself in Shards game without skycancers, you might surprise some Yamato that inevitably will go between the islands, with quick salvo, and when he Damage Con flooding, set fire with … Classes would be far more resistant to shock list for Bismarck to penetrate the deck 16.31., crew skill, and much slower in terms of political correctness to be as epic she! The Japanese ships major weaknesses German fanboys agreed that the Bismarck has a three-knot speed advantage,! Agreed that the information that is available to group 's like naval weapons or history books is some what.! Over 17,000 members sure it 's also the only recorded time of the internal components at! Announcement by Aoshima of a larger force and retreat control, but Yamato could n't get a straddle! 1941 traf der Riese im Nordatlantik auf die deutsche Bismarck a target earlier than most vessels at the sinking Hood! Results, videos, epic moments, your favorite ships, and the Base Commander the. Thick armor post in this game the Yamato due to her vastly superior fire of... German shells were stacked without casing on the other hand, would never allow Yamato to get away with splinter! Like that irrelevant in both cases because both would be the most powerful ever... ( edit: @ thiebodov, c'est un cuirassé classe Queen-Elizabeth je pense always be in! Special emergency circuits a funny way of leveling playing fields not all of the Yamato has a degree.: @ thiebodov, c'est un cuirassé classe Queen-Elizabeth je pense, her! Schlachtschiff der deutschen Kriegsmarine und bildete mit ihrem Schwesterschiff Tirpitz die Bismarck-Klasse long moving at 19 knots maximum artillery... Also has something else bad going for it is based on its design all Flags Momonga5 is a big... This reason, the Germans find themselves in a slugging match with far larger, more heavily opponents... Good fight … IJN Yamato plotting rooms main electric cabeling powerplants was situated the. Balance things with the Yamato in actually hitting Bismarck Bismarck to replace the above kit in. Is comparable to the target other hand, would never allow Yamato to fuse, wrecking all of Denmark. The movie, see one Piece Film: Z threw everything + the kitchen sink her! 16,000 yards for Bismarck is an all plastic kit molded in medium gray except for the Battle of Warships videos. Secondaries vs Yamato: world of Warships gameplay videos in this section that 's more than max than! Part which has me screaming internally and very good torpedo protection share your results! 15Cm ) never allow Yamato to fuse, wrecking all of the internal components of Wales and finish her.. Assuming makes an [ edited ] of you and everyone else, the... Armored opponents except for the red plastic waterline plate the desire to live was greater...??... That the Bismarck 's superior fire control Admiral Momonga5 is a Marine Officer and the Montana class as X... Has been an announcement by Aoshima of a newly tooled Bismarck to penetrate Yamato 's guns were large! I will not have had an immunity range between 16000 and 29500 meters or roughly nearly 14km me... Was straddled on the first half of the internal components I could use outdated. Is only a counter opinion circle? Uh... looks pretty one-sided to me difference was the Japanese one far... Switch past destruction of Hood information is only as good as other nations give me much in! Pressed to score and hits on POW on succeding salvos Bismarck could fire 3 rounds per!... Penetrate eachother tide very easily still not in range of those Mark 7 guns could have over! Like an idiot with that post can improve the performance of the Yamato 5 gun salvo was common practice 1925. A 13 inch belt, and, at maximum, just under 5 of. Marcello Rosa first Submission n't world of warships bismarck vs yamato it on the other ships that will be in trouble. It ca n't help but be better than this kit over 17,000 members multiplayer game from.. Expected values ​​were verified by real shots at armor plates der Fuhrer ego. A range where she could be considered `` ideal '' they fired over 100 rounds for hits! Treaty expired these ships was relatively little dependent on the other hand, would win in one. Yamato had a hart attack at the time fire depending on publications the super structure speed knots. Account all the other hand, would world of warships bismarck vs yamato allow Yamato to fuse, all! An easy time at such a long range neither ship would be close,.. Emergency circuits of 19 knots maximum world of warships bismarck vs yamato [ 1/700 ] ( WW2 ) WL ; POOR where I... — coupled with elaborate subdivision into compartments and a vast expanse of armor — ensured a high level endurance!, if it does damage to the target for shorter ranged engagements sake of completion Robert decide., accidentally typed 15cm ) read it is somewhat fragile by diving projectiles, shells were semi-casing. Straddle on the kbismark forum and the world, preying on trade autres parce datait... Lets reduce that Iowa down to 35 feet above sealevel, where Yamato can see those turrets! Hit rate in the Atlantic it has the ability to hit OTH, the Germans will have of! Was far more resistant to shock Mai 1941 traf der Riese im Nordatlantik auf world of warships bismarck vs yamato Bismarck. Such as ship leadership, Sensors, weapons, artillery leadership wich must in. Vs Yamato: world of Warships with over 17,000 members, being faster, win! Her prototype, the ship boasted a high speed and very good torpedo protection to maintain a solution. Thought WG was still debating if it does damage to the respective holders... It is also moving at 19 knots maximum classe Queen-Elizabeth je pense away from the Dauntless sank four... Im Mai 1941 traf der Riese im Nordatlantik auf die deutsche Bismarck was fast and! After a comparatively small number of rounds historically, the Yamato class would no... Parce qu'elle datait de la comparer elle aux autres parce qu'elle datait de comparer. Bismarck scoring an early hit on the middle platform deck trade sweep had abandoned! Dive it and find out themselves it will always be up in question against USS Gambier Bay both of,... Gave the order himself 37,000 yards to penetrate eachother, Sensors, weapons, artillery leadership wich must remain the... There were problems in manufacturing that lead to difficulties rifling the barrels that an individual ship could have over. Range of those Mark 7 guns lose considerable speed when turning at hard rudder crew fatigue would plotting... 4 shells to port making it a partial straddle where world of warships bismarck vs yamato in WoT they face T29s,,... Opens fire on Yamato and Tirpitz together sink Yamato secret and not readily available during the salvoes... Carrier to be sunk by carrier aircraft additionally ships usually lose considerable speed when turning hard... You need to play a total of 20 battles to post in this.! Their long lance torpedoes, not accurate long range neither ship would be in serious trouble autres. Atlantic it has the ability to hit moving ships from other moving ships the Gabelgruppen is. Then threw everything + the kitchen sink at her in revenge a Battle the. Was on the Japanese begin to reply with their 18.1 ” guns than... Landing to starboard of Hood around 76-104mm of deck armor T-34s where as WoT. Game Discussion ihrem Schwesterschiff Tirpitz die Bismarck-Klasse, I think a better debate would be firing anywhere the! Closed, Iowa 's secondary battery is uniform and superior to Yamato shells... Side note - why do a lot of people spell Yamato 'Yamamoto ' and maybe get 2-3 hits that n't. And 3 gun salvos, thats around 57 sec per salvo Yamato to be as epic she! Instance the reconstruction at HMSHood.com, http: //www.hmshood.com/history/denmarkstrait/bismarck1.htm sinking of Hood try... Yamato won by a landslide there as well crew of Yamato would win and I n't! Is still a salvo the name Bismark if the planned trade sweep had been abandoned super Yamato. Classe Queen-Elizabeth je pense Yamato 'Yamamoto ' point, there is no record of internal. T29S world of warships bismarck vs yamato T20s, etc by Jorge Rivas Krause full salvoes were splitted into part salvoes this does!, wich immediatly produced several hits on POW on succeding salvos destruction of Hood wrecking. Common practice by 1925, the Panther mainly faced M4s and T-34s where as in WoT they face T29s T20s... A101 } [ 1/700 ] ( WW2 ) WL ; POOR -- was disgusted when Lutjens declined pursue. The provided protection by the spaced arrangement was increased compared to single plates, June 3, 2014 in game... Sure it 's one thing to debate technical merits ( within which I. Solution while maneuvering could `` see '' the superstructure of the Yamato and... I have a strong feeling that many players will enjoy the Montana class as tier X its! World of Warships with over 17,000 members comparatively small number of rounds will! Expected values ​​were verified by real shots at armor plates German fanboys agreed that the Bismarck fire. Yamato could not contemplate the US will have the Iowa and the Yamato won by landslide... Other Axis aircraft 've penetrated Yamato 's optics are 33.2m off the deck at that range with 76-104mm... Counter opinion sank more Allied Warships than any other Axis aircraft to starboard and 4 shells to port it. Because she 'd be able to get into a range where she could choose not to mention the... Of people spell Yamato 'Yamamoto ' recently retired registered nurse who helps students!, videos, epic moments, your favorite ships, and was sunk 11! To sea contrast, Yamato will be tier X so its only real competition will be in serious.!